\"Just poke a hole in it\": why Reddit is full of bad recycling advice
The aerosol-can hack going around recycling subreddits isn't just wrong — it's dangerous. And the official system is the reason it spreads.
Spend an hour in any recycling subreddit and the same questions keep surfacing. Can I recycle this aerosol can? What about the plastic cap? Does my council take them?
People want to do the right thing. The problem is that the answers they're getting are vague at best and dangerous at worst.
The useless advice: "make sure it's empty"
The most upvoted reply on these threads is always some version of: "just make sure it's fully empty."
Sounds reasonable. It isn't.
What does "empty" actually mean? You spray until nothing comes out? It has to be silent when shaken? What if the valve is broken and you can't empty it? Nobody knows. Different councils have different definitions, none of them are visible at the point of disposal, and the public is left to invent its own rules.
The dangerous advice: "poke a hole in it"
This is where the comments cross a line. A surprisingly common "hack" gets repeated as if it were official guidance:
"My council says to poke a hole in it before binning." "Hammer a nail through the side to let the gas out."
Do not do this. Ever.
A partially full aerosol can is a pressurised metal vessel. Puncturing it with a sharp object is a reliable way to send hot, flammable propellant — and shrapnel — directly into your hand or face.
It is also a major hazard at the recycling facility. Compactors crush cans. A "harmless" hole-punched can still contains residual propellant; under compression that ignites. Aerosol cans are one of the most common causes of MRF fires in Europe. That advice you saw on Reddit may have started a fire several countries away.
Why this happens
The Reddit user isn't the failure point. The communication system around them is.
Aerosol guidance varies by city, region and country. The rules sit on outdated council PDFs, in untranslated leaflets, behind broken government links. There is no single, plain-language, EU-wide standard for what to do with a half-full deodorant can.
When official information is fragmented, myths fill the vacuum. That is the actual lesson here — not "the public is uninformed", but "the system never made the right answer easy to find."
What should change
- One pictogram, EU-wide, for aerosol disposal. Not 27 versions.
- Take-back points at supermarkets for partially full cans, the way batteries already work.
- Clear labelling on the can itself — printed by the brand, not buried in a council leaflet.
Until any of that exists, the safest thing you can do with a not-fully-empty aerosol is treat it as hazardous waste and take it to a household chemical drop-off. Leave the screwdriver in the toolbox.